I’ve never thought of myself as squeamish. But lately I find myself cringing at some of the blood and gore.
Have you seen the TV show The Following? Gad. Fortunately the setting is a large city, which is good, because as many people as they are killing off each week, it won’t take long to decimate an entire small town.
It makes me wonder if we’re to the point that it takes a lot to shock us. Maybe we just aren’t that easy to scare anymore. We’ve been desensitized to the point that even deaths need to be more shocking, more bloody, more bizarre. If you haven’t seen this TV show, it began with a woman stabbing herself in the eye. It gets worse.
I’m not sure I need this. I scare myself all the time with the characters I write. I don’t want to meet any of my villains in a dark alley, thank you very much. But I have never gone in for the gory, bloody, horrendous acts of violence in my books. I like more subtle, psychological evil. It scares me plenty.
Recently I began writing a romantic suspense with a villain who is so dark that I’m wondering if he is too awful – or if there is such a thing. How much evil do readers want to experience while reading a book?
Last night I was at my quilt club and one of the avid readers mentioned that she can watch really gory, scary shows and movies, but she can’t read books like that. The books are too real. Or maybe her imagination is.
I wrote a book some time ago about child abductors. The book, Twelve-Gauge Guardian, has continued to be one of my bestsellers. My heroine in the book was abducted when she was a child. She managed to escape and, now grown, has come back to catch the people who took her. My editor was concerned it would put readers off. It apparently didn’t.
As a writer, I have to get into the minds of my villains, but I scare myself enough that I often have a gun handy – and I know how to use it.
I know it’s a dark world we live in, but do we purposely scare ourselves with books, movies, television shows to face our fears? Or just for the adrenaline rush? I read somewhere that Stephen King wrote about his fears to keep them from coming true.
I write suspense because I love mysteries – and seeing the bad guy get his/hers. I want justice. But how far do readers want the villain to go before they are screaming for his blood?





















Add to Google

I love Kevin Bacon, so I’ve been meaning to catch that show, but I haven’t seen any. I’m not a gore fan. I think I keep my villains pretty bearable. I do a lot off the page, hinting at things that were done or show the after effects of things he did. I have found readers don’t appreciate it when animals are killed. Kill all the people you want but don’t touch that stray dog.
LOL Kendra! Isn’t it funny how readers don’t mind you killing people, but don’t you dare hurt that dog.
I killed a crow in Redemption. It was really sad. Readers agreed. But a crow isn’t a dog or cat.
Can’t wait to hear what you think of The Following!
After two episodes, I took The Following off my DVR’s auto-record. It was just too much for me. I’ve also decided to pick and choose which episodes of Criminal Minds I’ll watch. The killers are getting so horrendous, I just don’t want to watch a show I’ve watched from the beginning.
As for writing in the villain’s POV, I like to show his creepy turn of mind, but the majority of his/her acts takes place off camera.
Glad to hear I’m not the only one, Marie-Nicole. I love twisted minds, but I’ve never been a serial killer fan.
I like villains who have a personal reason for killing. But that’s just my preference. I have friends who love serial killers and write great serial killer books.
But I remember when I was reading Stephen King’s Misery. There were parts where I wanted to put the book down.
Love this post because it’s been a topic of conversation between me and my writing AND non-writing friends lately. I tried THE FOLLOWING, but it was too dark for me. When a female character I was invested in (sympathetic to) was killed off in the pilot gratuitously, I was done. Tune in every week to see the good guys try to track down the bad guy? Sure. But come back week after week to see more people slaughtered in more and more shocking ways? Not for me.
In my mysteries, I typically show the body/crime scene AFTER the murder has occurred, which removes the reader from the actual act.
Stephanie, I can’t tell you how glad I am that I’m not alone in this.
I thought I was just being a wimp about this show. I love Revenge, but it is personal — and not so gruesome.
I agree. When they got us invested in the victim who got away — and they killed her, it really set the stage for what was to come.
Yes, I like THE FOLLOWING. It’s a dark, twisty, psychological masterpiece with amazing actors. That alone is worth it — a good story well told — or well acted.
However, I could NOT watch THE KILLING which wasn’t as violent. Why? The victim was a 17 year old high school senior. At the time, I had a 17 year old high school senior. I cried in every episode. It hit far, far too close to home. She had two little brothers, I also have two sons who were about the same age. I stopped right before Rosie’s funeral.
THE FOLLOWING is not gratuitous IMO, though it is dark and edgy. I don’t think they go TOO far, but just to the edge. I like that it’s smarter than the average serial killer show, and I like the twist of a brilliant psychopath having followers — some who are far less brilliant (and more typical.) And I think I figured out who the “follower” is in the FBI (okay — I’m 2 episodes behind. What sold me though was that it’s a short season — 13 episodes. That I can handle, and it makes a perfect story arc (AHS, JUSTIFIED, etc all have 13-show seasons.) This isn’t a show I can watch one right after the other, I have to be in the right frame of mind. Unlike, say, JUSTIFIED or NCIS that I can watch repeatedly.)
LOL Allison. It is fun to see how different we all are. I have friends who can’t watch any kind of scary show.
I’ve never seen The Killing, but I love Justified, which gets pretty bloody sometimes.
I think The Following hits on more than just the violence. It scares me. Part of it is not knowing who is the good and bad guys. But it still makes me cringe. The chick with the knife gives me chills.
I tried one episode of THE FOLLOWING. It just isn’t my cup of tea. I found WAIT UNTIL DARK far more frightening! That is STILL the scariest movie I’ve ever seen!!! Of course, as a former CSI and forensic photographer, blood and gore doesn’t really bother me. The mind is much scarier than reality.
I have a villain who totally freaks me out. I’ve been writing that book 20 years. Every time I have to spend time in his head, I want to scrub with bleach and I can’t touch the MS for a very long time (years). I will finish the damn thing one day just to get it done and put away.
Great topic today, B.J.!
Thanks Silver. It’s interesting to see what everyone thinks.
I was a huge fan of Wait Until Dark too. I sent my parents to see it. They didn’t know what it was about.
I didn’t realize that some people can’t take scary movies.
I’ve been watching The Following. I sit there with my mouth open, thinking ‘how twisted are people?’ And Joe (what a bland name, huh?) is magnetic, I can see how he could collect a following.
LOL Jill.
That’s me — sitting there with my mouth open. It’s cutting edge, no pun intended.
Not a fan of the gore and blood. I don’t like to read the specifics of the killer gutting his victim, actually I don’t read it, I skip past.
I do like the suspense part though.
Catherine, thanks for weighing in.
I love the suspense too.
I’m glad I’m not the only one who found The Following gruesome. I don’t need quite that level of realism. The suspense part works for me, the not knowing and puzzling but not the blood.
I agree, Shelley. It is good to hear that I’m not alone as well.
I think what bothers me is when the show is on. I’m sure there are parents who will let their kids watch it.
B.J., thank you for this…:) I thought I was the only one!
In the past year or so, my tastes have changed considerably. Was flipping channels one day, and ran across SILENCE OF THE LAMBS. For years, that has been like a Bond movie: no matter how many times you’ve seen it, you can’t help but get pulled into it. This time, I kept going until I found a Three Stooges Marathon…:)
Would not miss CRIMINAL MINDS, barely glance at it anymore. THE FOLLOWING was so stupid in the first ten minutes I passed. (Using wrong term to classify the Unsub, the computer forensics was ALL wrong, and we won’t talk about the dog.) Not even remotely curious about the upcoming HANNIBAL.
I spend a lot of TV time these days locked into Turner Classic Movies…:)